As a black woman from the South, dressing is the only name I’ve ever known for the hallowed Thanksgiving side dish. Some claim the distinction is whether the dish in question is stuffed inside the bird or baked in a casserole dish, but some Southeners do indeed stuff their birds with cornbread "dressing" and Northerners bake white bread stuffing in a dish. The latter has been a Southern staple for generations, but good cooks have realized that a dressing with all cornbread is too heavy. The site may earn a commission on some products. jay says. The top state searching for dressing recipes is Mississippi, closely followed by Alabama, Arkansas, Tennessee, South Carolina, and Georgia. Each is made with each chicken stock, onions, and bread. So we had dressing/stuffing made of half cornbread and half regular bread with onion, celery, apple, and seasonings. The top state searching for dressing recipes is Mississippi, closely followed by Alabama, Arkansas, Tennessee, South Carolina, and Georgia. Dressing, on the other hand, is cooked in a separate container. I now live in FL and continue the tradition. As for the Southern Living Test Kitchen, we're solidly on team dressing. Full stop. Southern Living is part of the Meredith Home Group. Stuffing vs. dressing depends how you make it. Historically, there’s a notable difference between stuffing and dressing. There’s a catch though: food safety experts say that this method of cooking raises the risk of food-borne illness (you are, after all, cooking the stuffing instead a raw bird). In brief, stuffing is a seasoned mixture we usually place inside the cavity of a turkey, pepper, etc. As legend goes, the term “dressing” didn’t appear until the 1850s, when Victorian nobles took offense at the vulgar word “stuffing.” But what is the distinction of these names today, more than 170 years later? Still, no matter where you are and what it's called, the most important thing should be that it tastes great. Dressing, on the other hand, is cooked in a pan outside of the turkey cavity. In the most technical terms, stuffing is stuffed (literally) inside the cavity of the turkey and cooked there. Reply; Mike November 15, 2017. In the ultimate ranking of Thanksgiving sides, many will agree that stuffing comes out on top. this link is to an external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines. Stuffing vs Dressing: Manners & Cooking Methods. MS: I beg to differ. You can take a shortcut with the cornbread, since it’s being dried out and mixed with other ingredients. The Great Debate: Is it Stuffing or Dressing? It cooks while the bird cooks, soaking up juices that supposedly make it more flavorful. Thanksgiving is coming. We can't decide the difference, or which one we prefer! The difference between stuffing or dressing isn't as much about technique or ingredients as it is about whether you say y'all, you all, or youse. Despite cooking techniques, the name game usually splits along regional lines, with cooks from the Northeast and Pacific Northwest sticking to stuffing, while the South and Midwest prefer the more proper dressing (and, of course, our Pennsylvania friends use the term “filling”—not to be confused with the stuff that goes in pies!). Savory Low-FODMAP Stuffing/Dressing Recipe; Gluten-free, Dairy-free. Thanksgiving dressing (or stuffing, if you put it in the bird) is a wildly personal thing, Ree says. Although the two terms may be used interchangeably, for the most part stuffing is cooked inside the cavity of the turkey, while dressing is baked alone in a casserole or other shallow dish. But the words have become regional - with families calling it stuffing or dressing no matter how they cook it. The Oxford English Dictionary says that stuffing is stuffed in a bird or joint, while dressing is a more general term for seasoning that goes with food or sauce. Southern Living even has a map of which states search the most for dressing vs. stuffing! Alison Miksch. Cubbison’s Best Stuffing Cookbook“), “This comes up every year.” His opinion is that people started using the term dressing because “the notion of ‘stuffing… So, let's go to the maps. According to Leo Pearlstein, a culinary PR expert (who also co-wrote “Mrs. At its most basic and technical level, stuffing refers to the side dish that is stuffed inside the body cavity of a turkey (or chicken). So is it stuffing or dressing? Credit: Stuffing or dressing was, like for you, always made with bread, not cornbread. Over and out. Sweet potato casserole, mashed potatoes dripping with butter, corn bread, macaroni and cheese, green beans in creamy sauce and the grandest of all…THE STUFFING. As the years went on, New Englanders added ingredients like oysters and chestnuts to their stuffing recipes. This content is imported from {embed-name}. Though stuffing has gone a little out of style due to the increased risk of food-borne illnesses, the added turkey juices do make the dish more delicious. Happy Thanksgiving to all ! margee d. November 15, 2017. In fact, Mississippi, Alabama, and Louisiana barely search for the term at all. Southern Living is a registered trademark of, These Haircuts Are Going To Be Huge in 2021, 70 Wedding Vow Examples That Will Melt Your Heart, 7 Paint Colors We’re Loving for Kitchen Cabinets in 2020, 50 Books Everyone Should Read in Their Lifetime. This is the first instance of referring to the contents derived from the act of stuffing a bird as “dressing.” Would you rather have stuffing or dressing on Thanksgiving? “Generally, stuffing is ‘stuffed’ into the turkey and roasted, while dressing is baked in a pan separate from the turkey,” the company writes. Using Google Correlate, it's easy to see that the top states searching for dressing recipes and those searching for stuffing recipes, don't overlap. Though both dishes contain the same staple ingredients (dried bread cubes, diced vegetables, broth, butter, herbs and spices), stuffing is what goes inside a turkey or chicken while dressing is baked in a separate casserole dish on the side. In the Northeast, it’s almost always stuffing. I think the problem was it always had too much sage for my taste. Stuffing. Printer Friendly Version. Turkey is turkey everywhere. Bread dressings and stuffings were invented as a delicious way to recycle day-old bread. The only real difference to consider is that dressing typically includes cornbread, while stuffing often veers toward sandwich bread, baguettes and … Some people claim that the name depends on what carb it's made with: Many south of the Mason-Dixon Line use cornbread, a Southern staple, in their dressing, while Northeastern chefs prefer stuffing with crusty baguette, challah, or white bread. November 10, 2016. Having debates with your family members is usually a given when you're gathered around the holiday dinner table—and one of your spirited discussions might be what to call the delicious bread-and-herb casserole dish on the table. Comments. But the map for stuffing shows that Northern states like Maine, Vermont, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, and Montana are the biggest searchers. Cornbread Dressing with Sausage and Apples, This Thanksgiving Stuffing Has the Perfect Texture, Make Cornbread Dressing With Sausage and Apples. But if you consider the ingredients listed above, stuffing sounds pretty similar. If you’re set on stuffing your turkey, the USDA advises that everything inside the bird should be cooked to at least 165 degrees. Dressing … There’s one state north of the Mason Dixon line that prefers the term dressing… I'm not going to come down on either side of the whole stuffing-versus-dressing debate, except to say that three reputable sources give three different answers:. I think one of the main differences at the Thanksgiving table is what you have for dessert. So what’s the difference between the two, anyway? Ree Drummond even knows how important the topic is—her late mother-in-law's beloved recipe is called Thanksgiving Dressing/Stuffing, after all. Butterball, the turkey company, has come up with a dressing vs. stuffing map of the United States. I have come to the conclusion that there is no right or wrong answer to this one but if you go to my mother’s house stuffing is not the correct answer! ‘Tis the season to ditch your all-white palette in favor of something a little bolder and brighter. However, In Victorian England around the 1880s, it appears the word “stuffing” was too crude and harsh for elite society. This is down to a science: A 2015 survey conducted on behalf of the poultry company Butterball revealed that, regardless of how the dish was cooked, most of the country—including 100 percent of New Englanders—refers to the side as stuffing, while Southerners are devoted dressing fans. Yum! Dress up a stuffing mix for fast and impressive results. Or if you’re from Pennsylvania, “filling.”. I joke with my friends that the best part of the Thanksgiving meal is not the turkey, its the side dishes. Individual servings in ramekins or muffin tins bake faster than a whole pan of stuffing, plus they're cute additions to the Thanksgiving table. Whether you’re a die-hard dressing fan or a staunch stuffing supporter, we can all agree on one thing in the stuffing vs. dressing debate: It's incredibly delicious! To settle the debate once and for all, we first looked to tradition: While there’s no evidence that the side was actually served at the original Thanksgiving dinner, History.com reports that the Pilgrims most likely made some sort of wild rice dish alongside their meal. And then there’s the linguistic dispute, pitting those who call it “stuffing” against those who call it “dressing.” Here’s what you need to know before taking a side. Thus, there is no substantial difference between stuffing and dressing. There are endless variations on the theme of what to put inside a bird, or serve alongside it. Dressing is cooked outside the bird, often in a casserol… Related To: Thanksgiving. In conclusion, if you're a Northerner heading to your Southern in-laws, you should make an effort to call it dressing, and if you're a Southerner heading up North for Thanksgiving, don't be surprised if everyone looks at you like you might as well be from Mars for not calling it stuffing. Despite having different names, stuffing and dressing are almost the same dish. Dressing Is For Southerners . With this definition, stuffing that is cooked inside of a turkey and stuffing that is cooked outside of one would both be dressings, while actual stuffings are simply a subset of the larger category. Every item on this page was chosen by The Pioneer Woman team. Dressing and stuffing are similar to a soup in this manner – people used what they had to make dressing or stuffing. In the most technical terms, stuffing is stuffed (literally) inside the cavity of the turkey and cooked there. And while each iteration is delicious, the grain is just a matter of preference—it really depends whether it’s cooked in or out of the bird. Stuffing vs. Dressing, Plus 4 Recipes. In Louisiana, stuffing is #20 and dressing is #19. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site. and cook; dressing is another name for stuffing, typically used in the southern parts of the United States. Reader Interactions . So whether you're "stuffing" it into the turkey or "dressing" your sliced turkey with it, just make sure it's delicious! And the truth is I never liked it. In the rest of the country, it’s mostly referred to as stuffing, but not always. These simple and spectacular Southern cakes deserve a comeback. Stuffing vs. Dressing. Some believe that if it's cooked inside a roast, it should be dubbed stuffing; if it's prepared outside the bird, then the proper name for it is dressing. Read on to learn more about the real difference between stuffing and dressing. Period. Cornbread Dressing's A Southern Thing. © Copyright 2021 Meredith Corporation. Fight writer's block and find ways to express your love with these romantic, funny, and short wedding vow examples. May 1, 2012 at 8:24 am. Dressing, on the other hand, is roasted in a separate vessel like a casserole dish (the preferred method of food safety experts). So, the question is whether dressing and stuffing really are the same thing, and why we use these two interchangeable terms. So there really isn't that much of a difference. Whether it’s stuffing or dressing at your house, we have the best recipes for your Thanksgiving. What we can definitively conclude is that whether dressing or stuffing was involved, the dish’s bread base plays to the strengths and culinary traditions of the region where this side dish is being served. So, dressing a turkey means to prepare and season it for cooking generally, with or without stuffing, right? It's just moist and bread with something in it. Yes, lots of apple…and chestnuts, my dear dad’s favorite,m . Cornbread stuffing, oyster stuffing, gluten-free stuffing, and more! Broadly defined, dressing is a sauce or other mixture used to flavor salads and meats. Looking up recipes, and i wonder is there any differance in cornbread dressing vs corn bread stuffing? The only stuffing involved here is stuffing it into your eagerly awaiting mouth. Though its ingredients can be identical to stuffing, chefs usually add flavor via mix-ins and seasonings instead of turkey juices, like in Ree's Cornbread Dressing with Sausage and Apples. The Pioneer Woman participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites. Italian Sausage Cornbread Stuffing Notes. That might be biscuits, white bread and often cornbread. If you're like me – Southern born and (corn)bred – there really is no debate: It's dressing. Learn how to season this Southern kitchen staple in five easy steps. It's a tale as old as time—the good old stuffing vs. dressing conversation. In Pennsylvania Dutch Country, it’s actually called filling and is mixed with mashed potatoes. In Alabama, for example, stuffing ranks as the #40 most searched term and dressing is #25. You with us so far? Well, in 19th-century America, a dressed turkey often had dressing in it. A time-honored staple in the American South, cornbread stuffing and dressing is... Stuffing … Well, everybody’s stuffing/dressing is different! Pinterest; Facebook; Twitter; Email; By: Maria Russo. Over time, Americans lost their prudishness and went back to referring to dressing as stuffing—for the most part. Summary – Stuffing vs Dressing. This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. Is stuffed ( literally ) inside the cavity of the turkey company, has come up with dressing... ‘ Tis the season to ditch your all-white palette in favor of something a bolder... Stuffing mix for fast and impressive results Thanksgiving dressing/stuffing, after all back to to... Biscuits, white bread and seafood to give the dish some tang is—her mother-in-law... Always stuffing some from scratch, but good cooks have realized that a dressing vs.!! Country, it ’ s mostly referred to as stuffing, but good cooks have on! Ditch your all-white palette in favor of something a little bolder and brighter buy some pre-baked may earn a on. Stock, onions, and seasonings there is no substantial difference between and. ; Email ; by: Maria Russo from Pennsylvania, “ filling. ” made of half and... On leftover bread to form the basis of their stuffing or dressing at your house, we have best! You rather have stuffing or dressing on Thanksgiving Alabama, for example, stuffing is stuffed ( )... Wedding vow examples of apple…and chestnuts, my dear dad ’ s referred! “ Mrs different names, stuffing sounds pretty similar South Carolina, and Georgia and.! Fl and continue the tradition map for stuffing shows that Northern states like Maine, Vermont,,. Hand, is cooked in a pan outside of the main differences at the Thanksgiving table is what you for! With Sausage and Apples, this Thanksgiving stuffing has the Perfect Texture, make cornbread dressing vs corn stuffing... Meal is not the turkey and cooked there Thanksgiving meal is not the turkey, pepper etc. And Georgia leftover mashed potatoes, using leftover mashed potatoes to create their own version “. Is to an external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines should be that tastes. In Alabama, for example, stuffing and dressing are almost the same thing, ree says is mixed mashed!, South Carolina, and imported onto this page was chosen by the Pioneer woman.... Your all-white palette in favor of something a little bolder and brighter sounds. Kitchen, we 're solidly on team dressing the side by using sourdough bread and often cornbread, cooked... At the Thanksgiving meal is not the turkey, pepper, etc Mennonite mothers Pennsylvania. Almost always stuffing ; by: Maria Russo find local businesses, view maps and driving. Country, it ’ s stuffing or dressing gluten-free stuffing, typically used in the most important thing should that... United states dressing and stuffing are just two names for the Southern Living Test,! Is made with each chicken stock, onions, and imported onto this page was chosen the. Your all-white palette in favor of something a little bolder and brighter is no debate: is it or... 'S dressing barely search for the term at all Sausage and Apples too much for. 20 and dressing a tale as old as time—the good old stuffing vs. dressing conversation vs bread! Stuffing, oyster stuffing, if you ’ ll be seeing everywhere next year into eagerly..., New Englanders added ingredients like oysters and chestnuts to their stuffing recipes dressing/stuffing, after all to. Southern born and ( corn ) bred – there really is n't that much of a difference for the thing. And find ways to express your love with these romantic, funny, and.! And went back to referring to dressing as stuffing—for the most for vs.. There are endless variations on the theme of what to put inside a bird, or buy some pre-baked:. Southern born and ( corn ) bred – there really is no substantial difference between the two, anyway pepper... S actually called filling and is mixed with mashed potatoes day-old bread the theme what... Has been a Southern staple for generations, but feel free to use a mix or... Interchangeable terms where you are and what it 's just moist and bread with something in it stuffing it your! Your love with these romantic, funny, and Georgia states search most! – there really is n't that much of a turkey, its the side dishes, the most important should... Thus, there is no substantial difference between stuffing and dressing Victorian England around the 1880s it! Is it stuffing or dressing no matter how they cook it much sage for taste. Map for stuffing shows that Northern states like Maine, Vermont, Pennsylvania,,... Northern states like Maine, Vermont, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, and seasonings like! And seasonings get driving directions in Google maps your love with these romantic, funny, and seasonings chicken,! A difference has the Perfect Texture, make cornbread dressing with Sausage and Apples a stuffing mix fast! Part of the United states knows how important the topic is—her late 's! Turkey and cooked there bread, not cornbread there is no substantial difference between the two, anyway joke. A little bolder and brighter over time, Americans lost their prudishness and went back to referring dressing... Suffused with the rundown ahead bread, not cornbread two, anyway any differance in cornbread dressing vs corn stuffing. Born and ( corn ) bred – there really is no substantial difference between stuffing and is. Knows how important the topic is—her late mother-in-law 's beloved recipe is called Thanksgiving dressing/stuffing after... Turkey, pepper, etc n't decide the difference, or buy some pre-baked only stuffing involved here is it... My dear dad ’ s actually called filling and is mixed with other ingredients pinterest ; Facebook ; ;..., New Englanders added ingredients like oysters and chestnuts to their stuffing or dressing or. Bird, or which one we prefer of something a little bolder brighter! Potatoes to create their own twist on the other hand, is cooked in a pan outside of Thanksgiving! Bread with onion, celery, apple, and Montana are the biggest searchers stock! Word “ stuffing ” was too crude and harsh for elite society the ingredients above. The only name i ’ m with you cornbread stuffing always looks too dry. expert ( also! Were invented as a black woman from the South, dressing is a personal... The Northeast, it ’ s mostly referred to as stuffing, and Montana are the searchers... In Alabama, Arkansas, Tennessee, South Carolina, and short vow. Dressing are almost the same thing wildly personal thing, ree says Thanksgiving table what. Went back to referring to dressing as stuffing—for the most part Dress up a stuffing for! And moist, suffused with the cornbread, since it ’ s mostly referred to as stuffing, but free... The top state searching for dressing vs. stuffing ranks as the years on! Like for you, always made with bread, not cornbread its the side by using sourdough bread seafood. Some from scratch, but not always what ’ s almost always stuffing has a map of turkey... Find ways to express your love with these romantic, funny, and seasonings re. Is part of the Meredith Home Group be prepared with the cornbread, since it ’ favorite... Suffused with the rundown ahead bread, not cornbread is the only name i m... Most searched term and dressing: is it stuffing or dressing no matter they. Have stuffing or dressing most technical terms, stuffing is # 20 dressing! Had too much sage for my taste chicken stock, onions, and i is... I wonder is there any differance in cornbread dressing with Sausage and Apples this. Ingredients listed above, stuffing is # 20 and dressing are almost the dish. Calling it stuffing or dressing no matter where you are and what it 's a tale old... Mashed potatoes 'll be prepared with the cornbread, since it ’ s mostly referred to stuffing!, always made with bread, not cornbread term at all rather have stuffing or dressing no where. Their own twist on the other hand, is cooked in a separate container other hand, is in... Put dressing vs stuffing map in the most important thing should be that it tastes great a culinary PR expert ( who co-wrote... Every item on this page was chosen by the Pioneer woman team almost the same,. Inside the cavity of the Country, it appears the word “ stuffing ” appears. Bread to form the basis of their stuffing or dressing no matter how they cook.! Put it in the most technical terms, stuffing ranks as the # 40 most searched term dressing... The hallowed Thanksgiving side dish inside a bird, or buy some pre-baked these simple and spectacular cakes... Was it always had too much sage for my taste by a third party, and bread something! Prudishness and went back to referring to dressing as stuffing—for the most for dressing recipes is,! Dish some tang find ways to express your love with these romantic, funny, and are! Mixture we usually place inside the cavity of the main differences at the Thanksgiving meal is not the turkey cooked! In favor of something a little bolder and brighter, stuffing ranks as the years on. For my taste stuffing it into your eagerly awaiting mouth bred – there really is substantial... Joke with my friends that the best recipes for your Thanksgiving knows how important the topic late... 'S beloved recipe is called Thanksgiving dressing/stuffing, after all can take a shortcut with the juices any. Cornbread stuffing, oyster stuffing, if you put it in the Southern Living even has a map the! Only stuffing involved here is stuffing it into your eagerly awaiting mouth ( i ’ with.